Formula 1

F1 stand-ins who starred and flopped

Jul 31 2020
By Edd Straw, Scott Mitchell, Mark Hughes, Matt Beer

Nico Hulkenberg has the chance to step straight into one of the most competitive cars on the 2020 Formula 1 grid after being called up by Racing Point following Sergio Perez testing positive for coronavirus.

While that’s undoubtedly a great opportunity given Racing Point’s strong current form, he’s doing so with zero experience of the car and having not raced in F1 since Abu Dhabi at the end of last season, after which he was replaced at Renault by Esteban Ocon.

That’s the tightrope all short-notice supersubs have to tread – knowing that they’ll inevitably be compromised to some degree by not being as well-prepared as they could be, but hoping they can either overcome that or critics will take it into account.

Many drivers have used those opportunities as a springboard to future greatness, while others surely regretted saying yes.

In the list below, we’ve focused on those who clearly fall one side or the other of the star/flop divide.

So for example while sending Pascal Wehrlein’s Sauber upside down while battling for last place might suggest Jenson Button’s stand-in role for McLaren when Fernando Alonso skipped the 2017 Monaco Grand Prix for the Indianapolis 500 was a flop, Button did make Q3 before a host of grid penalties for component changes kicked in.

And speaking of Alonso’s McLaren-Honda stand-ins, we’re not going to judge Kevin Magnussen’s Melbourne 2015 effort either way given how few laps the car managed all weekend even before it failed on the way to the grid.

But here are some subs we feel it’s fair to judge – and we’ll start with the positives.

STAND-INS WHO STARRED

Kamui Kobayashi

Toyota 2009

Kamui Kobayashi Toyota 2009

Kobayashi’s European single-seater career appeared to have run out of steam as the 2009 GP2 season came to an end. Despite title success in the shortlived GP2 Asia series, he was far less effective in the main championship.

But then Timo Glock crashed in qualifying for the Japanese Grand Prix and suffered a leg injury caused by ballast held in the nose piercing the cockpit.

Kobayashi was Toyota’s test driver so was the logical choice to replace him for the last two races of the season – especially as he’d filled in for the ill Glock during Friday practice at Suzuka.

With expectations low, he surprised by qualifying 11th and finishing ninth at Interlagos – playing a part in fellow Toyota protege Kazuki Nakajima crashing on the way by moving over on his Williams on the run to Turn 4. But he followed that up with sixth place in Abu Dhabi.

Those two outings allowed Kobayashi to earn a full-time F1 seat with Sauber in 2010, laying the foundations for a decent F1 career that included a visit to the podium at Suzuka in 2012. – Edd Straw

Pedro de la Rosa

McLaren 2005

Pedro de la Rosa McLaren 2005

Making your McLaren debut in your mid-30s is a daunting challenge in itself, let alone doing so as a substitute. Yet Pedro da la Rosa produced the goods on his first start for McLaren in 2005, standing in for the injured Juan Pablo Montoya in Bahrain.

He outqualified team-mate Kimi Raikkonen and banked points with a fifth-place finish in the race, before giving up his seat to another member of this list – Alex Wurz.

But better things were to come for de la Rosa, who was picked to replace Montoya again a year later, only this time on a more permanent basis as the Colombian left the team.

A slow start hurt his prospects in the 2006 French GP, limiting him to a seventh place finish, while an early fuel-pump failure ended de la Rosa’s German GP on the third lap.

It all came together next time out in Hungary, though. A good start from fourth on the grid meant de la Rosa ran third early on, then second for a while behind Raikkonen. In the chaotic race that followed he never dropped lower than fourth and emerged on top of a duel with the great Michael Schumacher to snatch second place.

De La Rosa scored points three more times for McLaren, including a brace of fifth-place finishes, before returning to testing duties the following year. And that Hungarian GP podium – his first and only rostrum in F1 – is the standout memory of his time as McLaren super-sub. – Scott Mitchell

Gianni Morbidelli

Ferrari 1991

Gianni Morbidelli Ferrari 1991

When Alain Prost and Ferrari’s relationship became untenable with one round of the 1991 season remaining, Ferrari protege Gianni Morbidelli was called up from Minardi – where he was in his first full season of F1 – to take the then-three-time world champion’s place.

Though not on team-mate Jean Alesi’s pace, Morbidelli kept his head in the saturated Adelaide race. When the Williams of Nigel Mansell and Riccardo Patrese, and the McLaren of Gerhard Berger all went off in quick succession, Morbidelli found himself elevated to a remarkable third place behind only Ayrton Senna and Nelson Piquet.

But according to the statistics, the lap Morbidelli spent in third never happened – the race was abandoned as the rain worsened and on countback he was returned to sixth place, for which he only got half a point as the race was stopped with only 14 of the planned 81 laps completed.

Adelaide eventually repaid Morbidelli four years later, when amid high attrition he scored an against-the-odds podium for Arrows. – Matt Beer

Alex Wurz

Benetton 1997

Alex Wurz Benetton 1997

Replacing the sidelined Gerhard Berger, Alex Wurz’s three-race stint as a substitute for Benetton finished with a sensational podium at the British Grand Prix.

Wurz edged out team-mate Alesi in an ultra-close midfield group in qualifying to start eighth, but rose to a shock third place via a one-stop strategy – which Wurz thought was “brilliant” from the team, and what he insisted was the cornerstone of the result.

But the pace and promise was there from the beginning. He fought for points on his debut in Canada before a transmission failure brought his race to an end, then outqualified Alesi for the first time in France. OK, a messy race followed, but he still ran inside the top 10 before his grand prix ended with a spin.

The potential was realised in full at Silverstone, though, and rewarded in kind: Wurz bagged himself a full-time drive with the team for 1998. – SM

Sebastian Vettel

BMW 2007

Sebastian Vettel 2007

Sebastian Vettel wasn’t quite halfway through a championship-leading Formula Renault 3.5 campaign he was hoping would lead to his Formula 1 debut, when he abandoned his championship-leading Formula Renault 3.5 campaign to make his Formula 1 debut.

The teenager had already made several grand prix weekend appearances with BMW Sauber by this point, driving in free practice at four events in 2006 and two at the start of 2007.

But when Robert Kubica was ruled out by the FIA medical delegate as a precautionary measure because of his huge Canadian Grand Prix crash a few days before, Vettel had his big break in the United States GP at Indianapolis.

It didn’t take long for his prodigious speed to show through: fourth-fastest and second-fastest in the first and third practice sessions, fourth again in the opening part of qualifying. In the end, seventh on the grid was a bit of a disappointment. But Vettel said: “I shall sleep better tonight because last night I had the unknown ahead about what will happen.”

If he had a nightmare that evening, it might have gone a little like the opening moments of his debut grand prix – an average start and then going too deep into Turn 1, taking to the grass to avoid rear-ending a Renault and dropping down the order, out of the points.

But Vettel regained his composure and, despite the difficulty of his strategy being compromised in traffic, worked his way up to eighth to end his debut with his first point in F1.

“In the end, when I saw the chequered flag, I was quite relieved,” Vettel admitted afterwards. – SM

Mario Andretti

Ferrari 1982

Mario Andretti 1982

Forty-two years old and out of F1 for almost a year, Mario – who’d won the South African and Questor Grands Prix for Ferrari back in 1971 – was called up in that tragic season in which the team had lost both Gilles Villeneuve and Didier Pironi (to leg injuries).

Andretti hadn’t been in a competitive F1 car since his title year of 1978 with Lotus. But this was Mario Andretti. No way was he going to deliver anything other than a star performance in what was the fastest car of the season.

He tested for half-a-day at Fiorano, turned up at Monza and stuck it on pole! Now that, kids, is how you do a stand-in. A turbo went south on him in the race, restricting him to third. He retired with mechanical problems in Las Vegas, but only after again outqualifying the team’s regular, Patrick Tambay. – Mark Hughes

Stoffel Vandoorne

McLaren 2016

Stoffel Vandoorne 2016

As reigning GP2 champion, Stoffel Vandoorne should have been on the Formula 1 grid full-time in 2016. Instead he was shipped out to Japan for a place-holding season – then hurriedly shipped to Bahrain to sub for Alonso and make his grand prix debut.

Most of his plane journey to the Middle-East was spent buried in notes from his engineers, and Vandoorne hadn’t tested the 2016 McLaren before. But he celebrated his 24th birthday in style by outqualifying team-mate Button, and went on to cap a very, very assured weekend with a hard-earned point.

The only note of concern was a slightly disappointing opening lap, which Vandoorne admitted was “a little bit difficult, debris left and right – it was pretty hectic in fact”.

But this was a mistake-free effort – “I was really focusing on that side of things” – and Vandoorne could rightly hold his head high, having scored McLaren’s first point of the season.

It showed exactly why Vandoorne was so highly-rated and promised so much. So it’s a shame this proved to be among his peak F1 performances. – SM

Mika Salo

Ferrari 1999

Mika Salo Ferrari 1999

After Michael Schumacher broke his leg at Silverstone, Eddie Irvine – whom Ferrari had already decided it was not continuing with after 1999 – became the de facto world championship challenger for the team.

But now he needed someone in his old role in the other car to take points off McLaren’s Mika Hakkinen. Step forward Hakkinen’s old foe, Mika Salo.

After a quiet beginning in Austria, Salo was embarrassingly beating Irvine at Hockenheim and was all set to win the race. Except of course, he wasn’t. He was just waiting for the call to move aside and wasn’t surprised when it came. He took a third at Monza too. – MH

Michael Schumacher

Jordan 1991

Michael Schumacher Jordan 1991

On paper, retiring with clutch failure moments into the opening lap is not a successful stand-in appearance. But the few yards of racing Michael Schumacher managed with Jordan were irrelevant alongside everything his single weekend with the team promised for the future.

Aided by funding from his sportscar employer Mercedes and a slightly misleading insistence that he was very familiar with Spa (as a spectator…), little-known young German Schumacher got the nod to step in when Jordan’s stellar debut season was disrupted by Bertrand Gachot being imprisoned for an altercation with a taxi driver.

Schumacher duly learned the circuit on a bicycle and stuck the Jordan seventh on the grid, four places ahead of veteran team-mate Andrea de Cesaris (whose fourth place in Monaco on his temporary return to Jordan in 1994 following Irvine’s race ban almost got him onto this list).

The early retirement was irrelevant. Benetton had seen enough to launch (and win) a battle for Schumacher’s services that would set him on course for his first world championships and the start of an era. – MB

Roberto Moreno

Benetton 1990

Japanese Grand Prix Suzuka (jpn) 19 21 10 1990

Ironically the man Schumacher ousted from Benetton had been a star sub for the team under a year earlier.

Sometime Ferrari test driver and 1988 Formula 3000 champion, Moreno had spent the first part of his F1 career slogging deeply uncompetitive AGS, Coloni and EuroBrun chassis around, driving for teams where just getting beyond pre-qualifying was an act of heroism.

But when Alessandro Nannini suffered his horrific arm injury in a helicopter crash, Moreno suddenly went from teams trying just to avoid embarrassing themselves too badly to a team fighting Williams for third in the constructors’ championship.

Moreno qualified a respectable two places and half a second behind team-mate Nelson Piquet in eighth at Suzuka. Then as the infamous Senna/Prost collision unfolded at the start, they jumped to third and fourth.

With Berger subsequently going off and Nigel Mansell’s transmission failing, that soon became a shock first and second – which proved to be Moreno’s sole F1 podium as even though he turned that chance into a full-time Benetton drive, it was all downhill thereafter. – MB

STAND-INS WHO FLOPPED

Luca Badoer (and Giancarlo Fisichella)

Ferrari 2009

Luca Badoer Ferrari Valencia 2009

Michael Schumacher was the first choice to replace Felipe Massa at Ferrari after the Brazilian suffered a potentially life-threatening head injury in qualifying for the 2009 Hungarian Grand Prix.

Ferrari even confirmed Schumacher’s comeback, only for it to be called off when it was clear he wasn’t ready for it, having suffered a major motorbike crash at Cartagena earlier that year that, while downplayed at the time, had been very serious.

With Schumacher out of the running, Ferrari called up long-time test driver Luca Badoer. While he had not raced an F1 car for just two months short of a decade when he made his comeback in Valencia, Badoer’s wealth of testing experience suggested he was a solid pair of hands for the job.

He proved not to be and qualified last for both his outings, finishing 14th at Valencia then 17th at Spa – extending his record for F1 starts without a point to 50.

Badoer was treated as a laughing stock, but the man who replaced him – Giancarlo Fisichella – showed how tough the job was by failing to score a point on his five outings in the car. And this was a driver who was active in F1 and who took pole position and finished second at Spa immediately before his move. – ES

Jacques Villeneuve

Renault 2004

Jacques Villeneuve Renault 2004

Called upon to stand in at the end of the year for the departed-in-a-huff Jarno Trulli, Villeneuve was probably a bit rusty, having sat out the season up to that point.

Statistically, he outqualified team mate Fernando Alonso twice from three attempts, but that was purely circumstantial. In reality the the 1997 champion was nowhere near the future champion’s pace.

But he wasn’t quite finished with F1, yet. His career would be properly finished off over the following seasons by rookie Kubica at BMW. – MH

Jean-Louis Schlesser

Williams 1988

Jean-Louis Schlesser Williams 1988

Double World Sportscar champion. Five-time Cross Country rallying champion. Double Dakar winner. But also the bloke who denied McLaren a clean sweep of the 1988 F1 season by colliding with Senna while being lapped at Monza.

With Mansell suffering from chicken pox, Williams used Martin Brundle as a stand-in at Spa then turned to another sportscar ace in Schlesser when an IMSA clash meant Brundle couldn’t stay on for Monza. In a tough Judd-powered year for Williams between its Honda and Renault eras, Schlesser’s lack of F1 experience meant he was nowhere near the respectable performance that established F1 racer Brundle had achieved at Spa.

But being off the pace was one thing. Wiping out the eventual champion in an incident that made Schlesser a laughing stock was another. – MB

Philippe Alliot

McLaren 1994

Philippe Alliot McLaren 1994

Alliot already had 107 Formula 1 starts but just half-a-dozen points finishes in limited machinery during his journeyman Formula 1 career when he missed out on a McLaren seat in 1994 to Brundle despite the team’s new engine partner Peugeot supporting his candidacy as a result of his pace in its sportscar programme.

But he did land a test role and when Mika Hakkinen was banned for the 1994 Hungarian Grand Prix, he finally got his chance.

Alliot qualified 0.869s slower and eight places behind Brundle and held 12th place in the early stages before pulling into the pits and retiring with a water leak after 21 laps.

Having had his chance to impress, any lingering suggestion that he might take Brundle’s seat was eliminated and after just one more start – in the following Belgian Grand Prix having rejoined old team Larrousse – his F1 career was over. – ES

Jacky Ickx

Ligier 1979

Jacky Ickx Ligier 1979

The beautiful Ligier JS11 had been the dominant car at the beginning of the season, taking both Jacques Laffite and Patrick Depailler to victories. Then Depailler flew his hang glider into the side of a mountain and broke his legs.

Ickx wasn’t old by this time, but his once-brilliant F1 career had fizzled out. He hadn’t been a force in grand prix racing for six or seven years.

But could the Ligier reignite it all? Sadly, no. He struggled to summon the desire needed to be fast in the brutal sliding skirts ground effect car and never showed even a flash of his old magic. – MH

Heikki Kovalainen

Lotus 2013

Heikki Kovalainen Lotus 2013

When Kimi Raikkonen dropped out of his drive with the cash-strapped Lotus squad for the last two races of the 2013 season after committing to back surgery (the legacy of a testing crash at Magny-Cours back in 2001), fellow Finn Heikki Kovalainen was the obvious choice to replace him.

His two-race deal started well, Kovalainen qualifying eighth on his first time in the car at Austin. He finished only 17th, but had been on course to take eighth place before a front wing problem developed, which was then compounded by KERS problems.

But his outing in the Interlagos season-finale was disappointing, following a so-so 11th in a rain-affected qualifying, he dropped to 17th by the second lap after struggling to build tyre temperature and never recovered.

At that point, he was still in the running for a return to a Caterham race seat in 2014, having been the team’s reserve driver that year. His mood matched the paddock gloom when I caught up with him long after the race and it was clear he was a man who knew an F1 career that included a victory and a pole position was over. – ES

Alex Wurz Benetton 1997

What did you think of this story?

Share via
Copy link

Adblock Detected

We have detected that you are using an adblocker browser plugin to disable advertising from loading on our website.
The revenue earned from advertising enables us to provide the quaity of content you're trying to reach on this site. In order to view this page, we request that you disable adblock in your plugin settings.
I have disabled adblock for this site. Reload this page.