Are points on F1 debut always a sign of future greatness? - The Race
Formula 1

Are points on F1 debut always a sign of future greatness?

Apr 3 2021
By Edd Straw

Yuki Tsunoda became the 77th driver in world championship history to claim a points finish on his debut with ninth place in the Bahrain Grand Prix last Sunday.

It’s a significant achievement for any driver to get on the scoreboard so quickly, but as good as Tsunoda’s performance in Bahrain was, does scoring on debut guarantee a successful future?

Before we can delve into the case studies, we need to whittle down the numbers. Twelve of those 77 drivers scored points in the points-paying Indianapolis 500s of 1950-1960, an anomalous set of races that had nothing to do with the rest of the world championship.

1957 Indy 500 Start

Those can therefore be discounted to reduce the ‘real’ number to 65.

The early years of the world championship also create problems. Inevitably, there were five debut points scorers in the inaugural race at Silverstone. Drivers such as Raymond Sommer, who finished fourth at Monaco in 1950 on his first world championship outing, had major wins pre-war and therefore hardly count as newcomers at this level.

There are also cases of shared drives among the 27 drivers to have achieved this feat in the 1950s.

But after the 1950s, the feat became rare, with seven instances in the 1960s, six in the 1970s and only three in the 1980s and ‘90s.

Tsunoda is the 16th driver to score on debut in the 21st century. One thing that links all of those names is that they are all very capable drivers, although the success and longevity of their F1 careers varies wildly.

Samstagstraining, Strecke, Mark Webber

Kimi Raikkonen was sixth on his debut with Sauber in the 2001 Australian Grand Prix, having been promoted when BAR driver Olivier Panis was given a time penalty for ignoring yellow flags.

The following year, Mark Webber (pictured above) took his famous fifth place for Minardi at the same venue. Given Raikkonen went on to be world champion and Webber won nine grands prix and came close to the 2010 title, that’s an encouraging precedent.

The next two cases are less positive. Timo Glock was seventh when he replaced Giorgio Pantano at Jordan for the 2004 Canadian Grand Prix. Glock had a successful F1 career, starting 109 races and twice standing on the podium, but never on the top step.

Formula 1 Grand Prix San Marino

Vitantonio Liuzzi was the next to do so, finishing eighth at Imola in 2005. This was during his drive-share with Christian Klien, but after four outings Liuzzi never returned to the seat and went on to race in F1 until 2011 but rarely with the success his talent once indicated might come.

Then comes a ‘holy trinity’ – Nico Rosberg (seventh, Bahrain 2006), Lewis Hamilton (third, Australia 2007) and Sebastian Vettel (eighth, United States 2007, pictured below) – who have shared the last 11 world championships.

In all, 10 out of the 33 drivers ever to win the world championship have scored points on debut.

Sebastian Vettel BMW Sauber F1

Since then, things have been patchier. None of the subsequent nine drivers have gone on to win grands prix, although Tsunoda is included in that number so hasn’t had the chance to do so yet.

For some, things never got better. Sebastien Bourdais (seventh, Australia 2008), Sebastien Buemi (seventh, Australia 2009), Kevin Magnussen (second, Australia 2014) and Felipe Nasr (fifth, Australia 2015) never finished higher than they did on debut.

Bourdais had the shortest F1 career of the 21st century debut points scorers, lasting just a season and a half – although he was unfortunate not to finish fourth on his debut given that’s where he was running when his engine failed close to the finish.

Paul di Resta Force India F1

Paul di Resta (10th, Australia 2011, above) had three good seasons with Force India in F1 before dropping out at a time when more drivers had to bring budgets – a one-off stand-in outing for Williams in 2017 aside.

Daniil Kvyat (9th, Australia 2014) and Stoffel Vandoorne (10th, Bahrain 2016) both failed to fulfil their early promise but retain a foot in the door through their reserve roles.

However, at the time they got on the scoreboard they were still both drivers with great potential on the way up.

Stoffel Vandoorne McLaren F1

The other 21st-century debut points scorer is Carlos Sainz, who was ninth in the 2015 Australian GP.

He’s now in his seventh season, with a career-making opportunity as a Ferrari driver and a couple of podium appearances already on his CV and every chance of emerging as a race winner in the coming years.

Carlos Sainz Jr Toro Rosso F1

Where Tsunoda will slot in among this group of drivers remains to be seen.

But what is clear from the names on the list is that all are drivers with significant ability, and while scoring on debut is far from a guarantee of F1 career glory, it’s a fine start that only drivers of a high calibre are able to do.

And given Tsunoda’s start and the pace of the AlphaTauri, we can at least be confident that he won’t be one of those drivers who never bettered their debut result.

What did you think of this story?

Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap

Welcome To
The Race

Thank you for joining The Race community! Your activation email is on its way. Just click on the link in the email to confirm your sign-up (and check your spam folder just in case).
Continue reading
Free Articles Read This Month

Join The Race Community

UNLIMITED FREE ACCESS
to the best motorsport coverage,
videos, podcasts and quizzes.
Get the cream of our content direct to your inbox.
Get involved and comment on content.

Join Now!

You Have
Reached Your Limit

The Race has been stopped as you’ve reached your article limit for this month.
To get UNLIMITED FREE access, all you need to do is register.
Click here to get started